|
Levels: |
0-2 pts |
3-5 pts |
6-8 pts |
9-10 pts |
Score |
|

Criteria: |
|
Meaningful
Development
of Ideas
|
Ideas are
unclear and/or not well-developed
|
Unelaborated
ideas that are not fully explained or supported; repetitive
details
|
Depth of thought
supported by elaborated, relevant supportive evidence provides
clear vision of the idea; contains details
|
Depth and
complexity of thought supported by rich, pertinent details;
supporting evidence leads to high-level idea development
|
|
|
Organization
|
Weak
organization of ideas. No apparent logical order of
presentation, unclear focus
|
Somewhat
unfocused and/or unclear. Content is loosely connected
|
Sequence of
information is well-organized for the most part
|
Careful and
relevant organization of ideas. Development of topic is clear
through use of specific and appropriate examples
|
|
|
Mechanics
|
Frequent errors
in spelling, grammar, and punctuation
|
Some errors in
grammar, spelling and/or punctuation, but they do not interfere
with clarity
|
Occasional
grammatical, spelling and/or stylistic errors and questionable
word choice
|
Nearly
error-free which reflects clear understanding and thorough
proofreading
|
|
|
Overall Design
--
Appearance
|
The appearance
of most slides seems so overwhelming that the reader is likely
to say, "Tell me what this is about."
|
The appearance
of some slides is cluttered, confusing and can discourage the
reader from further study of the contents.
|
The appearance
of the slides are somewhat cluttered and requires some effort by
the reader to grasp the subject and the meaning.
|
The appearance
of the slides are uncluttered and instantly conveys subject and
meaning to the reader. The author has taken full advantage of
the medium to engage the reader and to convey ideas.
|
|
|
Creativity
&
Effects
|
Project includes
little variety in presentation techniques. Effects are limited
or not present.
|
Material
presented with little originality or creative thought. One or
more than one type of effect is used; however, some or all
effects detract from presentation.
|
Some apparent
originality displayed through creative use of materials. More
than one type of effect is used. Effects enhance presentation.
|
Exceptional
originality of presented material. Effects are varied, yet
cohesive, and they significantly enrich the presentation.
|
|
|
Presentation
|
Careless,
hurried, and messy presentation. Color or other appropriate
technique is not used to enhance important information.
|
Project appears
rushed and somewhat careless. Color or other appropriate
technique may be used to enhance important information.
|
Clear,
uncluttered, and attractive presentation. Color or other
appropriate technique is used to enhance important information.
|
Evidence that
pride and care were taken in presentation.
|
|
|
References/
Bibliography |
No references
given or many errors in the formatting of the Bibliography.
|
Few references;
a few errors in formatting of Bibliography.
|
Use of
references indicate some research; very little errors in
formatting of Bibliography. |
Use of
references indicate substantial research. Formatting of
Bibliography is nearly perfect.
|
|