Matrix of Student Responses Concerning SYETP
Cross-Classified by Issue (Row) and Group (Column)
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Where Students Learned About SYETP |
Family members (4) School/teacher/TAP (3) Newspaper/ads (3) Employer |
Relatives (6) Newspaper/radio (4) School counselor |
What Participants Liked Best about Summer Program |
Got more job experience (3) Meeting new people (2) Help from staff Help from co-workers Learned new job skills |
Got more job experience Help from staff "People cared about you" Meeting new people New experiences Job itself was enjoyable |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Greatest Barrier/Obstacle to Job Performance |
None (6) Office visitors Not respected as a professional/looked down upon Learning to use the equipment |
Too much "busy work/" dead time (2) Conflict with supervisor Too much close supervision Interference from co-workers' parents Competitive work environment Communication problems with co-workers Lack of access to equipment |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
One Thing that Would Have Helped Students Do Their Job Better |
Don't know/no response (8) More info about the organization, its rules & operating procedures To feel freer to ask questions Didn't want to provide advanced training to "temporary" workers |
More money (greater salary than minimum wage) - general agreement To not have to "cover" for other workers |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
(For women only) How They Were Prepared to Think About/Work In "Nontraditional" Jobs |
Given info & opportunities but chose "traditional" jobs (7) |
Given info & opportunities but chose "traditional" jobs (2) Liked to work outside, so wanted to try a "nontraditional" job No such thing as "nontraditional" job anymore - men & women are doing all kinds of work |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
How SYETP Staff Treated Student Workers |
Treated me well (3) Felt respected/"treated me like an equal" (3) "Willing to help in any way" |
Treated me well (4) Felt respected/"treated me like an equal" (3) Felt patronized/treated like a little kid Experienced communication conflicts |
Any Training to Help Students Understand Other Cultures |
No (10) |
No (10) |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Quality of Planning of Summer Workshops & Jobs by JTPA Staff |
Career Day was 'boring'(8) Should match activities to students' interests (e.g., Business fair for those interested in Business) (3) Need more small-group activities (3) Need more input from students themselves (vs. planned speakers) Got to practice interviewing Workshops should "stay the same" |
Felt "talked down to" Wanted to be paid for attending training Inefficiencies in training & job placement Should try & match job placement to students' interests Should lower the age of eligibility of students Should keep minimum age of eligibility at 16 (2) |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Students' Ranking of Staff's Performance |
Good (9) Excellent |
Excellent (2) Good (2) "Okay, all right" (4) |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Some Things the Staff Could Do Next Year to Better Prepare Students |
More focus on matching career choices with available jobs (5) "Not repeat stuff"/new workshops, activities (2) |
Make seminars/training optional so as not to disrupt job duties (2) Better information dissemination (2) Request more detailed job descriptions from prospective employers More focus on matching career choices with available jobs (2) Expedite interview process More field trips More realistic job placements |
Issue |
Group 1 |
Group 2 |
Any Other Comments? |
None |
Start the program earlier Provide an opportunity to make more money |